Try 1 tablespoon of jojoba oil -( seasame or grapeseed oil)
1 table spoon of distilled or filtered water
And 1 1/2 teaspoon of witch hazel
Mix it and see how it works then triple recipe or adjust to your liking ( keep the WH on low side). You can also try to use a few drops (2-3 of remover and few drops of water) so you are not going threw so much just dilute